Every product we recommend is carefully researched, fact checked and tested where possible. If you buy from a link, we may earn a small commission. Learn more.

William-Charles-300-Litre-Garden-Compost-Bin-Review

4smile Garden Compost Bin2022 Review

At first glance, it’s easy to see why the 4smile Garden Compost Bin is such a bestseller – it has a good capacity, can slot in neatly alongside other rectangular bins, and is simple enough to use. Granted, there are several other compost bins out there that look very similar to this one, but this bin seems to offer a few extra features, so I was excited to get it up and running on my farm to see how it compared to the rest.

4smile Garden Compost Bin Review

  • Where to buy
  • Our Scoring
    Assembly Ease
    Design
    Ease of Use
    Value for Money
    Overall
    4.125
  • Capacity
    300 L
  • Shape
    Rectangular
  • Assembly Required
    Yes

Back To Contents

Our Verdict of The 4smile Garden Compost Bin

Although this bin isn’t ideal if you want to add kitchen and garden scraps on a daily basis, or turn the contents regularly, it can still be very useful. Iif, like me, you usually fill your compost bins in bulk, and you prioritise a bin that’s large and sturdy, then this is one of the best compost bins to go for. Yes, it has a few flaws, but these won’t interfere with its ability to make good compost. Pair that with its low price and you’ve got yourself a great deal!

B002DXRJBA
8711295776861

Assembly Ease

William-Charles-300-Litre-Garden-Compost-Bin-Review-assembly

Like many of the other compost bins that I reviewed, this one comes flat-packed. However, unlike some of the others, it didn’t require any tools for assembly. All of the parts click together pretty easily. You most likely won’t need the instructions, which is good seeing as the ones provided are pretty poor.

I started by assembling the sides, before clicking the front hatch and the lid into place. Unfortunately, while doing so, I ended up snapping off one of the plastic lugs on the lid. This didn’t affect how the compost bin functioned, but the brittleness of the plastic did put me off slightly. That said, I did appreciate the simple assembly. All in all, it took me about 10 minutes to put this compost bin together.

Design

William-Charles-300-Litre-Garden-Compost-Bin-Review-design

With a 300 litre volume, this compost bin has quite a large capacity. You wouldn’t really want to go too much larger, as this would mean that the waste would take longer to break down.

It’s 83 cm tall and 61 cm wide/deep, which, again, is an ideal size. The bin is rectangular, so can easily be lined up next to other straight-edged bins. At just under 5 kg, it’s also light enough to move around the garden if you ever need to. Keep in mind that there’s no base to this bin (which, in my opinion, is a good thing as it encourages the worms to enter), so, if you do move it, you’ll be leaving your compost behind. 

A couple of other design features that I appreciated were the orange tabs that lock the lid down (very important when you live in an exposed and windy area!), and the small hatch at the front that opens up to give you access to the finished compost. There are also plenty of holes all over the bin to allow for good ventilation. 

Now, things that I didn’t like: the plastic that has been used to create this compost bin is quite thin. Most plastic compost bins out there, including the Blackwall Composter that I reviewed, are made from a hard, flexible plastic. However, for some reason, the designers of this product chose to go with a very thin and brittle plastic. It makes the bin feel flimsy and left me with doubts about how the material would hold up to multiple seasons of hard frosts.

Ease of Use

William-Charles-300-Litre-Garden-Compost-Bin-Review-ease-of-use

I genuinely thought that, out of all of the compost bins I tested, this one would be the easiest and most convenient to use. It’s a great size and shape, but there were a couple of points that left me disappointed. 

To start with, there’s no way to prop the lid up when you’re filling the bin. On a windy day, it’s a constant battle to keep the lid open while you’re filling it. If you plan on only occasionally adding new material in, then this won’t be a huge issue, but it’s not a bin that I would want to be filling every day. 

Also, because of the brittle plastic, you have to be very careful when turning your compost. Hit the plastic too hard with your garden fork and you’ll end up breaking some of it off or piercing a hole into it. Again, not an issue if you don’t plan on turning your compost, but this isn’t a bin for those who like to turn their compost regularly. 

Fortunately, neither of those problems were deal-breakers for me. I have compost bins dotted all around my farm, some of which I fill in a day and then leave for a year, without turning the contents. So, this bin fits in just fine!

Value for Money

This compost bin seems like a bargain at first, but it’s easy to see how it can be priced so low once you’ve felt how thin the plastic is. When I first set it up and started using it, I wasn’t sure how durable this bin would be, and therefore I was uncertain as to how much value for money it actually offered. 

However, two weeks later, Storm Arwen hit my farm hard. Like I said earlier, I have several compost bins dotted all around the place, and this was the only one that stayed standing. It was in a windier and more exposed spot than my other compost bins, to the point where half of my nearby field shelter went flying over the top of this bin, but this compost bin didn’t budge. After that, I was very impressed – there’s nothing holding this bin to the ground and it was only half full at the time, so it’s definitely a lot sturdier and more robust than it seems. 

For this reason, I’d say that it offers fantastic value for money, and I have no concerns at all about this bin holding strong for several more windy winters. 

Overall

4 4.125

Although this bin isn’t ideal if you want to add kitchen and garden scraps on a daily basis, or turn the contents regularly, it can still be very useful. Iif, like me, you usually fill your compost bins in bulk, and you prioritise a bin that’s large and sturdy, then this is one of the best compost bins to go for. Yes, it has a few flaws, but these won’t interfere with its ability to make good compost. Pair that with its low price and you’ve got yourself a great deal!

Back To Contents

Product Price Comparison

Every day DIY Garden scans thousands of products to help you find the cheapest prices. Not only do we want to help you find the best products through our in-depth testing, but we also want to help you find the best places to buy them too. We’re working hard to expand our network of retailers, and will be continually adding in new options.

The Cheapest 4smile Garden Compost Bin Found Today

Prices last updated: 17 May, 2022

Back To Contents

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

As you found this post useful...

Follow us on social media!

Related Articles
Scroll to Top